This is a compilation of the comments made by commentators regarding the Detroit Lions moves on the first day of the league’s window for lawful tampering. Grade for the Athletic Trade: B These ratings should sit well with everyone since, based on what I mentioned on X (previously Twitter), either the Lions or the Bucs decisively won or lost the transaction. It all boils down to Davis’ availability in the end. This will be a wise trade for the Lions as they look to challenge for the NFC title once more if he finishes the season mostly healthy, even if it’s simply matching his career high of 14 starts.
If Davis isn’t well, though, it will be similar to 2023, when the Lions signed defensive back C.J.
Gardner-Johnson and Emmanuel Moseley, just before they both suffered serious injuries. That apocalyptic situation would change how people view the trade.” Trade grade for CBS Sports: B+ “After being aggressive at cornerback the year before with limited success, Detroit most definitely needed to address the position. One year after rupturing the ACL in his left knee, Emmanuel Moseley played just two snaps in coverage before being out for the season with a torn ACL in his right knee. After signing a three-year contract in free agency, Cam Sutton gave up five throwing touchdowns and an 80.4 passer rating in coverage during the previous campaign. The Lions paired Sutton with Davis in the final year of his contract by using their available cap space to take a gamble on him. Although he doesn’t immediately know defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn or defensive backs coach Deshea Townsend, he will be expected to help a pass defence that finished the regular season allowing 28 pass touchdowns (ranked 28th in the NFL) and 7.8 yards per attempt (ranked 31st).” The Detroit Lions advanced to the NFC championship game, but they won’t be content with a defensive roster that needs improvement in 2023. In order to shore up its questionable secondary, Detroit traded for Tampa Bay Bucs third-round pick in exchange for cornerback Carlton Davis III. The Bucs also sent the Lions sixth-round selections in 24 and 25. Set to earn $14.5 million, Davis was about to enter the final year of his deal. In 2022, Davis agreed to a $44.5 million, three-year contract deal to stay in Tampa Bay. The Lions are hopeful that after two difficult seasons in a row, he will have a strong year and help improve their subpar secondary. Last season, the Lions added cornerbacks Cameron Sutton and Emmanuel Moseley, but their additions were ineffective on the field. For Detroit’s cornerbacks, Davis will bring much-needed depth and competition.
Antoine Winfield Jr., Baker Mayfield, Mike Evans, and the Buccaneers all had deals that required them to generate financial room, and they had plenty of depth in the secondary. The Lions’ third-round selection might be used by the Buccaneers to replace Davis.” ESPN Trade classification: B-.Getting a cheap cornerback who was previously excellent is usually a wise business move. Players can rise or fall in this position year after year due to its extreme volatility, so sometimes the best course of action is to back the man you believe has the potential to be a No. 1 cornerback and hope that variance will work in your favour. The drawback is that by giving Davis a $14 million one-year contract in exchange for a third-round pick, But Detroit isn’t buying that cheap. Think about this: a year ago, the Dolphins acquired Jalen Ramsey for a third-round selection. Ramsey was earning about the same salary as Davis (the Lions would owe him $14 million in 2024) and had an additional year of guarantees. However, Ramsey is a superior player.
However, it’s evident that the Lions needed to take action to improve their secondary. Their attempts a year prior were unsuccessful due to injuries that ended the careers of C.J. Gardner-Johnson and Emmanuel Moseley, while Cameron Sutton’s performance was subpar, allowing 1.4 yards per covered snap and a plus-18 EPA. The Lions’ fifth-worst EPA per play of 0.08 is a serious blow to their chances of winning the championship. They needed to take action.”Pro Football Network”Probably the top priority on Detroit general manager Brad Holmes’ list of things to accomplish was to find a No. 1 cornerback. When playing at his peak, Davis can provide perimeter play that is comparable to a shutout. Davis, who was selected in the second round of the 2018 NFL Draft, is still only 27 years old. His aggressiveness should make him popular with both Aaron Glenn and Lions head coach Dan Campbell. He can hold up in man coverage in Glenn’s defensive system. With 60 pass breakups between 2019 and 2022, Davis was second in the NFL to James Bradberry.
Detroit might have a strong nickel package with Davis and Cameron Sutton on the outside with 2023 rookie sensation Brian Branch in the slot. Nonetheless, the Lions’ secondary, which struggled last season, will still lack depth. Davis missed five games in 2023, four in 2022, and seven in 2021, demonstrating that he is not immune to injury.”